I started the car and backed out carefully. Even then, even in that moment, some old reflex inside me wanted to leave neatly, without spinning gravel, without drawing notice, without giving anyone a reason to say I had stormed out. Years of being the reasonable one do that to a person. They teach you to package your pain politely. They teach you that if you are not careful, the story will stop being about what happened to you and become about how inconveniently you reacted to it.

We drove three miles before the first question came.

The party had been at Carol’s place outside Lexington, in one of those subdivisions built fast on former horse land where every backyard seems big enough for a trampoline and a grill but not quite big enough for privacy. The road out opened into a wider county route lined with gas stations, Baptist churches, a Dollar General, and a row of maple trees already dusty with summer. I kept my eyes on the lane ahead and told myself to get to the next stoplight. Then the next one. Then the next.

From the back seat, Lily spoke in a voice so careful it almost broke me.

“Did we do something wrong?”