Royal expert Tom Quinn suggested that the timing of the announcement was deliberate, sending a message to Harry that he remains estranged from the family. “Harry was in tears when he heard,” Quinn said. “What makes it worse is that the role is going to the man Harry blames for much of his troubles—his brother. And the announcement during Harry’s short UK visit was no coincidence; it was meant to hit home.”

The decision is particularly poignant considering Harry’s military service in Afghanistan, where he formed a deep personal connection to the Army Air Corps. Pandora Forsyth, a royal commentator, told Sky News that William is the “right fit for the role” and that Harry was aware he would have to relinquish his honorary military titles when he stepped back from royal duties. “It’s brutal,” she said, “and very personal for him.”

In his memoir, Harry described William as both his “beloved brother and archnemesis”—words that feel especially fitting in light of this latest family development.