The claims mirror similar online debates surrounding the family’s 2023 Christmas card. In that black-and-white image, observers pointed out that William’s legs appeared to be missing behind Charlotte’s chair, while others noted that Louis’ middle finger seemed absent.
Following the release of the 2025 card, one Reddit user commented: “Kinda looks fake, to be honest.”
Another wrote: “Boring and fake. They love cosplaying the middle-class farmer family look.”
A third added: “Kate looks like she was added in the photo. Her hand seems like she’s wearing a different shirt and isn’t even holding Prince George, it’s around something else. It’s so bizarre. They could even snap a pic at the Christmas Concert.”
Others echoed similar thoughts, with one asking: “Were any of them actually together when they took the picture, or is it another Photoshop?”
Another declared: “Kate looks like she was added in,” while a final Redditor agreed: “She does. Her hand looks Photoshopped onto George.”
