Then she picked up the framed photo on his desk. It showed Thomas at ten, standing beside Richard on the bow of the company’s first commercial vessel. Both wore captain’s hats. Both smiled into the wind. Thomas’s small hand was lost inside Richard’s enormous one.

“Where did we lose him?” Eleanor whispered.

The question hung unanswered.

The next morning, Charlotte arrived carrying a pink bakery box from the pastry shop on Oak Street where Richard used to buy almond croissants on Sundays. She stood at the penthouse door wearing jeans, a navy coat, and an expression too anxious for her age.

“I hope it’s okay that I came,” she said. “Dad’s been… difficult.”

“You are always welcome here,” Eleanor said.

They sat in the kitchen over tea. The city below was bright and cold, sunlight bouncing off the lake like broken glass.

Charlotte opened the box but did not take anything.

“They’re talking about selling the house,” she said. “The art collection too. Victoria says they’re suddenly cash-poor because of you.”