Not everyone was so kind. “She wearing a black sheet? Who died?” one person quipped. Others questioned her outfit pairing, with one noting, “A strange outfit from Meghan — the top and skirt don’t match or complement,” and another writing, “It’s a formal occasion and you wear a stretch material shirt and a different material skirt??????”

Despite the online chatter, Meghan and Harry appeared relaxed throughout the night, mingling with guests including Serena Williams and other celebrity friends. The debate surrounding the Duchess’s look, though, suggests that no matter the occasion — or the outfit — Meghan Markle continues to spark conversation wherever she goes.