When I handed her the keys a week later, she broke down crying. “I never thought I’d have a daughter,” she whispered as she hugged me.

That was three months ago. My family still tries to reach me through mutual friends and distant relatives, but I’ve cut those ties, too. Sarah sent a letter claiming she’s changed, that she’s sorry, that she needs help with the baby. I threw it away unopened.

Instead, I have weekly dinners with Elizabeth. We’re getting to know each other, sharing stories about James—the good and the bad. She’s helping me see that while he wasn’t the man I thought he was, that doesn’t invalidate all the happy moments we shared. Yesterday, I finally packed away James’s remaining things. Elizabeth helped me donate some to charity and store others in the attic. As we worked, she told me stories about James as a little boy, before the lies began. It helped somehow to know that version of him existed.