Five years passed. I stayed in the same house. I poured everything into my students.

“Ms. Carter, look at my picture!” a boy named Jacob once shouted.

“It’s wonderful! Is that a puppy or a dinosaur?”

“Both!” he grinned.

Routine became survival.

Then came a Monday morning like any other.

I parked in my usual spot and whispered, “Let me make today count.” The school buzzed with its usual chaos. I handed out tissues, began the morning song.

At 8:05, Principal Alvarez appeared in my doorway with a small boy clutching a blue backpack.

“Ms. Carter, this is Mason. He just transferred.”

He stood beside her, brown hair falling into wide, watchful eyes.

“Hi, Mason,” I said gently. “We’re happy you’re here.”

He tilted his head slightly before offering a shy, crooked smile.

That’s when I saw it.

A crescent-shaped birthmark just beneath his right eye.

My breath caught. Ethan had the same mark. Same place.

Glue sticks slipped from my hand and clattered to the floor.

“Uh-oh, Ms. Carter!” little Sophie chirped.

“No harm done,” I forced a smile.