The woman on his arm—her—studied me with a measured, almost curious gaze. Her eyes lingered on my cardigan, my scuffed heels, the lines under my eyes I hadn’t even realized had deepened over the years.

It took me a moment to place her face. Then memory struck.

An old photograph I’d once found in Steven’s college yearbook: a group shot at some party, him with his arm around a girl in a floral dress, both of them grinning like the world was about to belong to them. I remembered asking, teasingly, “Who’s she?”

“That’s Genevieve,” he had said back then. “My first love. She broke my heart and taught me humility.”

He’d laughed when he said it. I’d laughed too, because that’s what you do when your husband mentions a girl from his past—someone different, someone finished, someone who existed safely behind glass in the museum of his memories.

I’d never imagined she’d step out of an elevator on his arm eight years into our marriage.

Now she gave me a small, almost indulgent smile and spoke before he could.