When I demanded an explanation Garrett insisted that he had not cheated on me and explained that before we met he briefly dated Angela, and two years earlier she had contacted him claiming he was the father of her child and eventually proved it through a DNA test.
Garrett admitted that he had secretly been sending financial support every month and had asked Angela to keep the girls apart once people began noticing how identical they looked.
However something still felt wrong to me because the resemblance between Hazel and that other child went beyond what half siblings would normally share.
“They do not look like half sisters,” I said quietly, “they look like twins.”
Garrett immediately rejected the idea until we realized that both girls were the same age and that Angela lived only two streets away from the hospital where I had given birth.
A horrifying possibility began forming in our minds. “What if the babies were switched,” Garrett whispered.
“What if someone did it intentionally,” I replied.