Then he noticed the broken plate.

The room went silent.

Melissa stepped forward sadly. “I didn’t want you to see that today. I know tomorrow is hard for you.”

Tomorrow was the anniversary of my mom’s death.

Dad sighed. “What happened?”

Melissa answered immediately.

“She smashed it. She was angry.”

“That’s not true!” I croaked. “It slipped!”

“Let Melissa finish,” Dad said.

My stomach dropped.

“She screamed at me,” Melissa continued softly. “Then she ran outside.”

“Dad, she dragged me!” I shouted.

Melissa laughed lightly. “Mark, do you really believe that?”

Dad looked at my scalp.

“It’s red,” he said slowly. “But you were outside.”

He didn’t believe me.

Melissa gently placed a hand on his arm. “She’s grieving.”

“How could I lock the deadbolt from outside?” I cried.

Dad hesitated.

“She has a point.”

For a moment Melissa’s face tightened—but she recovered.

“I locked it because she ran out screaming. I was scared.”

Dad sighed heavily.

“Enough. Go take a shower, Emily.”

“What about her?”

“Go to your room.”

Upstairs, the hot water burned my skin.

Through the vents I heard them arguing quietly.

“You can’t let her talk to me like that,” Melissa said.

“I know,” Dad replied. “She’s struggling with the anniversary.”