Then Detective Cole told me something else.
Something worse.
They had found messages on Andrew’s laptop proving Melissa hadn’t just suggested violence.
She had picked a date.
That date was the following Sunday.
My baby shower.
My mind went blank.
My mother had ordered decorations. My sister had organized food. Friends were traveling to celebrate.
Melissa had chosen the event because it would be crowded. Loud. Chaotic.
The perfect moment for an “accident.”
But by then, the police had a different plan.
The shower would still happen.
Only this time, officers would be watching.
The day arrived.
My family surrounded me with nervous smiles. One plainclothes officer pretended to be a distant cousin. Another waited outside in an unmarked car.
My mother held my face gently.
“We finish this,” she whispered.
Andrew arrived wearing a blue shirt and carrying a wrapped gift. His expression looked exactly like it had for years—calm, caring, convincing.
For a moment he seemed relieved to see me surrounded by family.
Then Detective Cole stepped out from the kitchen hallway.
“Andrew Bennett,” he said clearly.
I will never forget Andrew’s face in that moment.
It wasn’t guilt that appeared first.
It was disbelief.