The crying did not move me the way it once might have. I do not mean that cruelly. Tears are not always false. But they are not always evidence of accountability either. Sometimes they are simply the body’s oldest instrument for regaining control of a moment. Carol cried and said she was “humiliated” to be accused of mistreating her own grandchildren. She cried and said her arthritis had been acting up and she had not been able to think straight. She cried and said Melissa had enough on her plate. She cried and asked if this was really how Daniel wanted to speak to his mother after all she had done for him.
The answer to that question, of course, was a history lesson she had no interest in hearing. What had she done for him? Raised him, yes. Fed him, clothed him, kept a roof over him. The baseline obligations of parenthood had, in Carol’s imagination, matured into permanent moral leverage. Families like that turn the ordinary duties of love into lifelong debt.