No one answered.

That was the cruelest part.

Mom kissed his forehead. “Tell the truth, sweetheart. Whatever happens, tell the truth.”

Noah swallowed hard.

“That night, I heard Dad scream. I went downstairs. The kitchen light was on. Dad was on the floor. Uncle Victor was standing over him. There was blood on his shirt. Mom wasn’t there. Then he saw me and told me to go upstairs.”

His voice shook, but he kept going.

“He picked up the knife with a cloth. I followed him because I wanted Dad. He went into Mom’s room and put the knife under her bed. Mom was asleep, or she looked asleep. Then he rubbed something on her robe. When he saw me, he covered my mouth and said if I talked, Claire would disappear like Max.”

I covered my mouth.

Max.

Our dog.

One week before Dad was murdered, Max disappeared. Dad told us maybe the gate was left open. I cried for days. Uncle Victor bought me a stuffed animal and told me bad things happened sometimes.

Now I knew.

It had been practice.

A warning.

Victor began sweating. “This is insane. You’re believing a traumatized child?”

Noah placed the plastic bag on the table. Inside was a small key.